Pimento Cheese

Have you ever had pimento cheese? An important caveat: have you ever had home-made pimento cheese? That neon colored sludge from the supermarket absolutely doesn’t count–that’s the stuff that gives pimento cheese a bad name. That junk forces anyone who doesn’t live in the south to think pimento cheese is somehow vile stuff. The real deal is not even close. Its nothing short of incredible really. Its a mix of sweet, sour, tart, rich, creamy cheeseiness.

Pimento cheese is actually very simple to make and uses a mix of other cheeses as a base (so don’t worry, you don’t have to make cheese from scratch for this). The end result is a cheese that is easily used as a dip or a spread. I like to fill omelettes with it and to use it as a topping on both burgers and sandwiches. Other common uses are on crackers and as the filling for grilled cheese sandwiches. Its works well in spreadable form or for melting applications. Ultimately, its fairly versatile stuff.

Flavor-wise, this rendition had a good mix of tart, dill notes, sweet pepper highlights, and a solid, smoky, cheddar backbone.

If you can work a food processor and have 5 minutes, you can whip up a batch of this.

You can find the original recipe here

  • 1 lb sharp cheddar cheese
  • 1/2 lb Monterey Jack cheese
  • 2 medium kosher dill pickles
  • 2 cloves of garlic
  • 1 4 oz jar of pimentos, drained
  • 3 Tbsp mayonnaise (if you have the option, Duke’s is an awesome brand)

Coarsely chop up all of the ingredients and throw all but the mayo into a food processor. Pulse until you’re happy with how well things are mixed. You don’t want to go for complete homogeneity–some chunk/texture is a good thing in pimento cheese (I think). Then, incorporate the mayo and transfer the mixture to the fridge for 30 minutes before serving so that things can firm up a bit more.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Be Sociable, Share!
  1. Enjoy this recipe? Never miss another!

Related Posts

10 Responses to “Pimento Cheese”

  1. alison Says:

    wonderful recipe!i made only fresh pimento stuffed with a mixture of cheese,butter and dill or other mixtures.

  2. nina Says:

    Yikes, Imagine stuffing a jalepeno with this, roll in phyllo and bake…….awesome. I’m going to give it a go!!

  3. The Duo Dishes Says:

    The pickles are a nice touch. This is one that the Southern grandmas used to make all the time. Addictive!

  4. Sonia (foodiesleuth) Says:

    Our family loves pimento cheese….I’ve never added the pickles into the mix, but do use a little bit or rough, country style mustard…..and yes….my mom was born in the South, so even though we were born and raised in Cuba we grew up eaten pimento cheese….and I agree with you on store-bought…ew!

  5. LaneyHaney Says:

    I’ve never tried pickles in it, but I may just work up the courage to try it. You’re right about Duke’s Mayo. It makes a super pimento cheese, potato salad, tuna salad, or anything for that matter. I also recommend JFG Mayonnaise, too, another great Southern brand.

  6. shayne Says:

    we are waiting for your return, hope all is well

  7. Cómo preparar queso de pimientos - El Gran Chef Says:

    […] a su familia con preparaciones caseras te recomiendo la siguiente idea. A continuación aprenderás cómo preparar un queso de pimientos. Tomaremos queso cheddar y queso Monterey Jack y le daremos un toque especial. Solo necesitas un […]

  8. Super Bowl Food Ideas from Mike's Table Says:

    […] Pimento Cheese […]

  9. Matthew Templeton Says:

    I’m not blessed with any cooking ability at all…luckily I can buy pimento cheese at Publix. It’s called Palmetto Cheese and is delicious.

  10. T. Charles Says:

    Palmetto Cheese is full of preservatives and other chemicals that you can’t even pronounce. Homemade is so easy, but if you MUST buy it in a store, buy Trader Joe’s or Miss Bonnie’s.

Leave a Reply